Yes’s latest studio album, Talk, released in 1994, was a commercial flop. However, Yes—comprising Trevor Rabin (guitars, vocals), Jon Anderson (vocals), Chris Squire (bass guitar), Tony Kaye (keyboards), and Alan White (drums)—persevered and went on tour to promote the album. The band played 77 concerts in the U.S., South America, and Japan, performing to audiences that were significantly smaller than before. This was likely Yes’s first theater-level tour since the days of The Yes Album (1971).
After the tour, Rabin had had enough. Rabin jumped ship in May 1995 and decided to try his luck as a film composer in Hollywood. The remaining four members were left without leadership or a record label. In the past, Anderson would undoubtedly have taken the reins, but he seemed to be at a stage in his life where he couldn’t muster the energy for true leadership. Another potential powerhouse, Squire, was also in a rough spot. Rumors of substance abuse problems and serious health issues were circulating, and apparently Yes was close to not going on the Talk tour without its founding member.
Tony Kaye went his own way (he opened a restaurant in California) in Rabin’s wake, and the remaining trio—Anderson, Squire, and White—were left wondering if they even had a band anymore. However, the trio hired a new manager, and soon the relatively small Castle Communications showed interest in releasing Yes’s music. Castle was signing up old-school artists to its roster and, around the same time, also brought Marillion on board. In practice, the new Yes album would be released on Castle’s sub-label, Essential.
Yes and Castle mutually agreed that the band’s upcoming tours would feature the so-called “classic lineup.” Steve Howe and Rick Wakeman would be brought back into the band. Anderson met with Howe and Wakeman in Los Angeles, and in July 1995, a deal was struck that ensured the return of the classic lineup. The quintet—Anderson, Squire, Howe, and Wakeman—had, of course, played together on the 1991 Union tour, but this would be the first time they’d create new music together since the late 1970s, when their attempt to make a follow-up to Tormato (1979) failed completely.
Yes’s original plan, however, wasn’t to make new music right away, but to release a live album that would, in a sense, announce their reunion, after which they could consider the future of new music. Castle, however, wanted new material right away, which ultimately led to a somewhat odd hybrid of live recordings and new songs.
The new studio tracks on Keys To Ascension were recorded before the live shows, but we’ll still cover the live songs first, since that’s the order in which they appear on the album itself.
Contrary to what one might have expected, the return of this classic lineup was not celebrated with a massive world tour; instead, Yes ended up holding two intimate concerts at the Fremont Theater (capacity: 650) in the small town of San Luis Obispo, California. Anderson was living in San Luis Obispo at the time, which explains the choice. Demand from the audience was significantly higher than expected, so Yes eventually added a third show. All three shows were recorded, and the last one was also filmed.
The shows, which lasted about two hours, consisted entirely of material from the ’70s, focusing mainly on music that the current lineup had originally helped create. In other words, even though Anderson’s vision for the classic lineup was to bring Yes back to making progressive music, the band paradoxically turned toward nostalgia during these shows. From then on, Yes’s setlists would consist mostly of old ’70s music from one tour to the next.
Read also: Yes: Drama (1980)
During the Keys To Ascension era, however, there was still the allure of novelty, as many of the songs now back in the setlist hadn’t been heard in decades. On the first Keys To Ascension album, such gems included “Siberian Khatru” and, in particular, the over 20-minute-long “The Revealing Science Of God,” which hadn’t been performed live since the original Tales From Topographic Oceans tour. Yes’s epic rendition of Simon & Garfunkel’s “America” was also a rarity at this point, one that hadn’t been heard in a very, very long time. “Onward,” heard on Tormato, had never been performed live before.
The other songs included in the set—“Siberian Khatru,” “Awaken,” “Starship Trooper,” and “Roundabout”—were more familiar fare. The latter two, in particular, had even been included on tours in the ’80s, while “Siberian Khatru” and “Awaken” had been part of the ABWH and Union tours.
But how did our heroes, now in their middle age (the members of Yes were in their fifties at this point), fare with this old and technically quite challenging material? The short answer is: well. The long answer is a bit more complicated.
Rumors circulate about extensive post-production editing on many live albums, and Keys To Ascension is one of them. According to numerous reports, Yes’s playing at the San Luis Obispo shows was tentative, and apparently the band’s collective rehearsal time was quite limited. Based on eyewitness accounts, it has therefore been widely assumed that the live performances were heavily edited in post-production. This is quite possible, but on the other hand, Howe’s bitter remarks about being left alone to handle the post-production phase—and that no one else really cared about the album’s fate—speak against this. It is, of course, possible that the other members came in to record additional takes, and Howe’s complaints may refer to the mixing phase, which he was left to oversee alone (though Anderson did stop by occasionally to check on the situation).
Since we can’t know the ultimate truth—and also because, especially in the case of big bands, post-production editing of live albums is, in any case, more the rule than the exception—I’m judging the quality of Keys To Ascension based on what my ears hear, without speculating on how the final result was achieved.
And the live recordings certainly sound great. Of course, the band doesn’t race through its material with the same intensity as in the ’70s, but the tempos are still lively and at least as fast as in the original studio versions. In true Yes style, the original arrangements are largely respected, though here and there the soloists take a few liberties by slightly altering or stretching them.
Perhaps the track that differs most from the original arrangements is “Onward,” which now sounds lighter and more acoustic than the overproduced version on Tormaton, bringing Howe’s beautiful acoustic guitar playing to the forefront. The brighter and lighter-sounding “Revealing Science Of God” will likely delight many who have found that epic challenging to digest, but for me, it doesn’t quite capture the original’s mystical atmosphere. Still, it’s an excellent and commendable effort—and proof that even the most complex material flows effortlessly and naturally from this lineup.
Of all the live tracks, however, “Starship Troopers”—which stretches to over 13 minutes—makes the biggest impression. It’s a truly mind-blowing performance. The now-traditional guitar/keyboard battle between Howe and Wakeman is waged this time at a breathtakingly fast tempo without compromising the musicality of the section. The version on Keys To Ascension is definitely one of the best—if not the best—live recordings of “Starship Troopers.”
The individual performances are consistently high-quality, but what delights me most is Chris Squire’s “return.” Whereas on Talk, Squire’s bass guitar remained very much in the background, he now takes on a more equal role alongside the other musicians and clearly plays with a delightfully nimble touch once again, even if his growling Rickenbacker doesn’t roar quite as powerfully as it did in its glory days of the ’70s.
But let’s move on to the studio material that Yes recorded in San Luis Obispo, in an old bank building they rented and converted into a studio. With the studio tracks on Keys To Ascension, Yes leaves behind the pop and AOR influences of the ’80s and turns its attention toward ’70s prog. The result is two long tracks, one of which—“Be The One”—is 10 minutes long, and “That, That Is” is a whopping 19 minutes long.
“Be The One,” credited to Anderson, Squire, and Howe, is divided into three parts. The song begins calmly, even a bit sluggishly, but comes to life in the second part, “Humankind,” where Anderson’s passionate and downright angry vocals, in particular, amp up the energy. Howe’s guitar also sounds suitably fiery, but overall, the band doesn’t quite shift into high gear. Anderson’s vocals are the strongest element of this section, but perhaps their excessive prominence in the mix slightly detracts from the rest of the band’s impact. Rick Wakeman plays a very minor role throughout most of the song, and he actually arrived at the studio sessions later than the rest of the band, which may explain his limited contribution. “Be The One” is pleasant to listen to, but it’s clear that the material had the potential to be better. As it stands, the song sounds a bit shaky and also a bit too long.
But all this senseless killing, and all these chains and lies
I want to know right now, I want to know right now
I want to know where we come from
For it’s a long, long way from where the system began
It’s a long, long way humankind
It’s a long, long way from where the system began
It’s a long, long way humankind, yea
“That, That Is,” which runs nearly 20 minutes, consists of seven sections, and this time the composition credits go not only to the trio of Anderson, Squire, and Howe, but also to White. The epic begins with the beautiful “Togetherness” section, which is essentially an acoustic solo by Howe accompanied by Wakeman’s light synthesizer playing. The second section, “Crossfire,” brings a slightly ethnic vibe, created especially by White’s nimble drumming and Anderson’s wordless vocals. The actual song finally kicks off with a fast riff that hums sweetly in the background and White’s bass drum pounding out a massive beat. Anderson is once again in an intense mood, and the lyrics unexpectedly shift from his typical cosmic realm to the streets of a big city. The lyrics lament the children caught in the crossfire of the drug war, and it’s actually quite strange to hear Anderson sing about crack addiction. Of course, the lyrics later shift to a more mystical plane, and angels sing “Shaava, shava shava-shaava”—whatever that may mean. I know that many Yes fans were appalled by the lyrics of “That, That Is,” but I find it interesting and refreshing that he juxtaposes urban tragedies with the ethereal spirituality more typical of his work.
All in all, “That, That Is” is quite an interesting journey through a variety of moods. The transitions from one section to the next are relatively smooth, but it’s clear that this is a sort of Frankenstein’s monster. “That, That Is” is certainly not the kind of coherent symphonic whole that Yes was once capable of at its best—when Anderson and Howe’s collaboration was still seamless—but rather a collection of shorter tracks that have been somewhat cobbled together. The album does offer some truly impressive moments, such as the aforementioned “Crossfire” and the closing track “Agree To Agree,” which is driven forward by Squire’s thundering bass riff, but the whole remains, like “Be The One,” somewhat disjointed.
Wakeman is a bit more prominent on “That, That Is” than on “Be The One,” but once again it feels as though either he wasn’t given any room in the original compositions or he simply had nothing to contribute.
“Be The One” and “That, That Is” show that Yes still had what it takes to deliver large-scale progressive rock, but unfortunately, the songs feel unfinished. Close To The Edge was polished to perfection over the course of months, and these compositions would have required a similar level of care. Production-wise, the studio tracks on Keys To Ascension sound like high-quality demos. It’s as if they were the result of the band’s first full run-through—a good starting point from which to build the final version. Judging by the end result, it seems that either time or money—or both—ran out before they could finish.
Shirley gets to help her with the child
Though she’s strung out on crack time
Shirley never knew what it was to be held in real love
Together getting high to get to mess up their night
Anything to get up so they’re losing their mind
Just to get high, breaking out from this life
Gotta get them a drug to get higher
Read also:
- Review: Kate Bush – The Kick Inside (1978)
- Levyarvio: Rush – Test For Echo (1996)
- Review: Steven Wilson – Requiem For A Village (2026)
- Levyarvio: Steven Wilson – Requiem For A Village (2026)
- Review: Van Der Graaf – Vital (1978)
- Levyarvio: The Tangent – The Music That Died Alone (2003)
- Year by Year : Best Albums of 1978 – 21-34
- Vuosi vuodelta : Parhaat levyt 1978 – Sijat 21-34
- Review: The Muffins – Manna/Mirage (1978)
Keys To Ascension failed to reverse Yes’s commercial decline. Quite the opposite. In the U.S., the album briefly reached No. 99 on the album chart, and in the U.K., it peaked at only No. 48. You’d have to go back to the days of Yes’s first two albums to find a result this poor. Combining live and studio material has rarely been a winning concept, and unfortunately, Yes was no exception to the rule.
It’s easy to be wise after the fact, of course, but it still seems somehow obvious that Yes’s strategy regarding the Keys To Ascension albums was completely wrong. The studio material on the first Keys To Ascension feels rushed, and sprinkling new music among old live tracks inevitably dilutes their value and tends to cause confusion about what the releases are actually about.
The obvious solution would have been to release the live material as separate albums and save all the new music for a single, carefully crafted studio album. In practice, however, this isn’t quite that simple, since the studio tracks for the first Keys To Ascension were recorded at the turn of 1995 and 1996, and those for Keys To Ascension 2 nearly a year later. In other words, we’re talking about a longer time span than there was back then between Fragile and Close to the Edge. With more careful long-term planning, this could still have been managed.
In my opinion, the best strategy would have been to release the new live music as a single, epic three-CD set that would have served as a sort of exclamation point, signaling that the classic Yes is back. The next step could have been to take a page from King Crimson’s playbook (more on this in the VROOOM review) and release “Be The One” and “That, That Is” as a mini-album that would have served as a taste of Yes’s future. The songs could have debuted on that album in their current, somewhat unfinished form, with more polished versions to follow in the next phase—which, of course, would have been a proper full-length studio album bringing together the best studio tracks that ended up on the Keys To Ascension albums. This album would then have been followed by a proper world tour. The end result would have been nothing but a win! Or maybe not, but at the very least, that strategy couldn’t have led to a worse outcome than what we actually saw. More on that in due time in the Keys To Ascension 2 review.
Key tracks ”Starship Troopers”, ”Onward”, ”Awaken”, ”Be The One”, ”That, That Is”
Author: JANNE YLIRUUSI
Read also: Yes: Mirror To The Sky (2023)
Tracks
CD 1 (65:23)
- Siberian Khatru (10:16)
- The Revealing Science Of God (20:31)
- America (10:28)
- Onward (5:34)
- Awaken (18:34)
CD 2 (50:38)
- Roundabout (8:30)
- Starship Trooper (13:04):
a. Life Seeker
b. Disillusion
c. Würm - Be The One (9:49):
a. The One
b. Humankind
c. Skates - That, That Is (19:15):
a. Togetherness
b. Crossfire
c. The Giving Things
d. That Is
e. All in All
f. How Did Heaven Begin
g. Agree to Agree
Jon Anderson: vocals, guitars, harp Steve Howe: 6- and 12-string guitars, pedal steel guitar, 5-string bass guitar on the song “Be the One,” vocals Chris Squire: bass guitar, piccolo bass on the song “Be the One,” vocals Rick Wakeman: keyboards Alan White: drums, vocals

St. Louis, Missouri, really? I think your auto-correct acted up there. Excellent review and article, though!
Yeah, I don’t know what happened! :D That is now fixed. Thanks!
Fascinating review! A couuple of corrections. “Onward” was never played live prior to 1996. ”Siberian Khatru” was not played by ABWH or on the Union tour.
Thanks for pointing that out! I’ve made the corrections.