Review: Rick Wright – Broken China (1996)

Broken China is Rick Wright’s second solo album.

Pink Floyd founding member and keyboardist Richard William Wright (1943–2008) cannot be described as a prolific musician. Wright played a significant role as a composer for Pink Floyd from the late 1960s until roughly the mid-1970s, but his output then began to decline. Wright played an important role in composing pieces such as “Summer of ’68,” “Atom Heart Mother,” “Echoes,” “Us and Them,” and “Shine On, You Crazy Diamond.”

During the last 30 years of his career, Wright played a significant role on a handful of albums. In fact, his departure from Pink Floyd came about because Wright prioritized his leisure time over music. Of course, his deteriorating relationship with Roger Waters—who had assumed a dictatorial role within the band—also played a part, but the final straw came when the band was recording The Wall under immense financial pressure and Wright decided to prioritize a vacation over studio sessions whose schedule had been disrupted. Wright has explained that he had to put his family first to save his marriage, but he himself has admitted that he didn’t have much to offer the band musically after Wish You Were Here. This greatly frustrated Waters, who was 100% dedicated to the band. After the vacation incident, Waters issued an ultimatum: either Wright would leave the band, or he would take The Wall with him. Wright relented, but he was at least allowed to participate as a session musician on the The Wall tour. After that, Wright was without a permanent musical home, and he spent much of the 1980s sailing around the Greek islands.

Wright, however, had begun his solo career with the album Wet Dream, released in 1978. Wright himself has described the lackluster Wet Dream as “amateurish.” Personally, I wouldn’t classify the album that way, but there’s certainly nothing to praise in Wet Dream’s completely toothless, light-Floyd-style sound, which at times even veers into yacht rock territory. A lackluster performance from a man who, just a decade earlier, had dreamed of composing a symphony. Wet Dream was hard to come by for a long time. The small print runs of physical copies had long since sold out, and the album wasn’t available on streaming services either. In 2023, the situation changed when Steven Wilson remixed the album. Wet Dream got a bit of a boost from this, but I still can’t really think of a reason to listen to it.

After being kicked out of Pink Floyd, Wright disappeared from the music scene for years, and music—or at least playing music—probably wasn’t part of his life at that time anyway. Eventually, as the mid-1980s approached, Wright attempted a comeback with Dave Harris, who had sung in the New Romantic band Fashion. Wright and Harris released the album Identity under the name Zee in April 1984. Wright has largely characterized Identity—which was created primarily using a Fairlight CMI synthesizer—as an “experimental mistake,” and this time I can fully agree with his assessment. Identity is a complete failure and a plastic-sounding piece of work.

Wet Dreamia and Identity had two things in common: neither album received praise from critics, and both were also commercial flops. So it’s no wonder that Wright returned to the helm of his yacht.

Soon, however, rumors began to circulate that guitarist David Gilmour was reviving the Pink Floyd brand against Waters’ wishes. Gilmour and Mason were already working on an album when Wright, encouraged (or pressured…?) by his wife, began lobbying for a role in the project as well. Eventually, Gilmour and Mason relented—largely because having three musicians with a Pink Floyd background would strengthen their position in the legal battle in which Waters was trying to block the entire project. However, Wright—whose playing was somewhat stiff—played only a marginal role on A Momentary Lapse of Reason, released in 1987. He sang backing vocals on a few songs and played a bit of Hammond organ in the background on a couple of tracks. The extensive tour for the hugely successful A Momentary Lapse of Reason was a revitalizing experience for Wright, both musically and emotionally.

The production process for Pink Floyd’s next album, The Division Bell (1994), was considerably more collaborative than that of its predecessor. This time, Wright’s keyboards and music were given more space, and his composition “Wearing The Inside Out”—which he also sang—was one of the album’s highlights. The Division Bell was, however, also a frustrating experience for Wright. Gilmour was still firmly in the driver’s seat, and Wright was particularly annoyed that the album lacked any of the themes typical of Pink Floyd that tie the different songs together (coming up with and developing these had always been Waters’s domain). After the long The Division Bell tour, Wright felt ready to compose his own music, and since a new Floyd album was not on the horizon, the time was ripe for a new solo album. He could make it as conceptual as he wanted.


Read also: Review: Pink Floyd – The Dark Side Of The Moon (1973)


The concept chosen was a topic as “cheerful” as depression. The album depicts an individual’s depression through the eyes of a loved one who watches from the sidelines, feeling more or less powerless. Upon the album’s release, Wright said that the subject was inspired by a friend’s battle with depression, but he has since admitted that it was actually about his girlfriend at the time, who later became his third wife. Adding a personal dimension to the theme is the fact that Wright has said he himself has suffered from depression from time to time and that, in fact, along with laziness, it has likely been another significant reason why he has found it so difficult to produce new music.

Although the subject matter was closely tied to Wright’s own life, he did not want to write the lyrics on his own. Anthony Moore (Slapp Happy, Henry Cow), who already had a background with Pink Floyd, was brought in to help. Moore had written the lyrics for three tracks on A Momentary Lapse of Reason, and for The Division Bell, he had written the lyrics for “Wearing the Inside Out” under Wright’s direction. The collaboration had worked well, and Moore was the perfect choice for the project also because he was a friend of Wright and his wife and could therefore relate to the situation better than a complete stranger. Moore also composed two of the album’s songs. The lyrics of Broken China have one very peculiar feature. The lyrics for two of the songs were written by Gerry Gordon, who is unknown in music circles. It later turned out that Gordon had been Wright’s wife’s therapist! Quite baffling.

Wright managed to assemble a veritable dream team of musicians for Broken China. Manu Katché was chosen as the drummer; Wright had set his sights on him after seeing him in action on Peter Gabriel’s tour. To accompany Katché on bass, they brought in studio veteran Pino Palladino. Guitar duties were shared between Dominic Miller and Tim Renwick. Steven Bolton plays rhythm guitar on one track. Jazz guitarist Miller is best known for his collaboration with Sting, and he plays the album’s most jazz-infused moments. Often on acoustic guitar. Renwick, for his part, had served as second guitarist on Pink Floyd’s tours from 1987–89 and in 1994, and it falls to him to play the guitar parts that sound like David Gilmour. In fact, Gilmour was originally supposed to appear on the album as well, but in the end, the part he played on the song “Breakthrough” wasn’t used. Was this Wright’s revenge for having his solo on the song “On The Turning Away” rejected in 1987? Well, maybe not!

The instrumentation is also supplemented here and there by Sian Bell on cello and Kate St. John on oboe and English horn. In addition, various—mostly tastefully programmed—rhythms play an important role in the soundscape, even though some of them clearly sound like products of their time. Wright himself plays the keyboards rather understatedly as part of the ensemble, often contributing only textural atmosphere. At times, Wright also gets carried away with light soloing. And on the track “Breakthrough,” we hear a magnificent Minimoog solo that is very much Wright’s trademark.

Wright sings most of the album’s vocals himself in a rough and somewhat fragile voice, at times sounding considerably older than his 53 years. Wright’s vocal performances, however, bring just the right amount of authenticity and soul to the album, even though he isn’t singing directly about his own life. It would have been a terrible mistake to bring in a powerful, clear-voiced Paul Carrack-type vocalist. Wright’s voice, however, is somewhat monotonous, so it was an excellent move to bring in Sinead O’Connor to help out on a few tracks.

It’s a bit surprising and amusing that the young and hugely popular Sinead O’Connor ended up working with three different, unfashionable prog rockers in the ’90s. Especially since I, for one, can’t seem to find any prog influences in O’Connor’s own music. In 1990, O’Connor performed at Roger Waters’ massive The Wall concert in Berlin, and a couple of years later, she sang a duet with Peter Gabriel on his album Us. The latter collaboration can probably be explained by the brief romance between O’Connor and Gabriel.

But whatever the reason for these guest appearances may be, O’Connor is the perfect fit for the Broken China album. The duet between Wright and O’Connor, “Reaching For The Rail” (featuring a very Gilmour-esque guitar solo), works particularly well, but “Breakthrough,” on which she sings solo, is also a soulful piece of work. O’Connor’s guest appearance is, in a way, also problematic because, next to her performance, Wright’s “old man” voice sounds even more weak than before.

Given the album’s theme, it’s probably no surprise that the music on Broken China doesn’t sound particularly cheerful; instead, it often swirls along, carried by dark synth pads, only to come vividly to life every now and then with harsher, more rhythmic passages. The music is characterized by a deep melancholy undercurrent of which, at times, a restrained rage bubbles up. Stylistically, Broken China can be described as an art rock album interspersed with a few ambient-inspired instrumentals. The music naturally echoes Pink Floyd, particularly in the guitar work and, of course, in Wright’s own keyboard parts. The connection to the mothership is also underscored by Storm Thorgerson’s very Floyd-esque, surreal cover art, in which a woman dives into a circle of water, shattering into porcelain shards.

In addition to Floyd, Wright seems to have drawn inspiration from the music of Peter Gabriel and David Bowie. In particular, I feel that Broken China shares some stylistic similarities with Bowie’s 1. Outside album (1995), even though Wright’s music doesn’t venture into quite such experimental realms. There’s something similar in the way Broken China and 1. Outside blend art rock with influences from 1990s experimental dance music. This is particularly evident in the excellent instrumental “Satellite,” which could be described as a mix of prog and trip-hop. Speaking of the rhythm section, it’s also one thing that clearly sets Broken China apart from Floyd. You’ve never heard a rhythm section groove as tightly as Katché/Palladino on a Pink Floyd album. Palladino’s bass playing, in particular, is truly magnificent to listen to in many places. Check out, for example, the aforementioned “Satellite”!

Recorded at Wright’s own studio in France, the album is a high-quality production that honors the Pink Floyd tradition. However, some of the rhythmic choices detract from the album’s timelessness and clearly anchor it in the mid-1990s. The recording was handled by Pink Floyd’s longtime collaborator James Guthrie.

The problem with Broken China is that, although it’s a work of relatively consistent quality, there isn’t standout tracks that would really tower above the rest. The O’Connor/Wright duet “Reaching For The Rail” and the intensely driving “Breakthrough,” however, are nearly there. I’ve also never really been able to grasp the album’s narrative. While the individual lyrics successfully paint a picture of a woman in a downward spiral, they don’t seem to form a particularly compelling story arc.


Read also:


Broken China received cautiously positive reviews from critics upon its release, but the album went completely unnoticed by the general public. In other words, it met the same fate as most of the other solo albums by Pink Floyd members. Perhaps partly for this reason, Broken China remained Wright’s last solo album. The lukewarm reception likely made it all too easy to step back into the background. This is a shame, because even though Broken China isn’t a brilliant album, it clearly reaches toward greatness, and I believe Wright would have had a chance to achieve it if he’d had the stamina to try one more time or persist. In any case, Broken China ranks among the very best of the Pink Floyd solo albums, alongside a couple of Waters’ solo albums and Nick Mason’s excellent Fictitious Sports. In fact, I enjoy it more than A Momentary Lapse of Reason or The Division Bell

After Broken China, Wright’s playing was heard only on Gilmour’s solo albums On An Island (2006), and he also became a regular member of the guitarist’s touring band. Wright also plays a central role on the Pink Floyd album Endless River, which was released posthumously and compiled from outtakes of the The Division Bell sessions. Otherwise, Wright focused on family life in France, sailing, and collecting Persian rugs.

Rick Wright, a gentle and reserved man who died of lung cancer in 2008 at the age of 65, may not have been a particularly prolific or hard-working musician, but there is no denying that he played a significant role in the creation of the classic Pink Floyd sound in the 1960s and 1970s. Broken China shows that he had more than enough potential to succeed on his own.

Best tracks: ”Night Of Thousand Furry Toys”, ”Satellite”, ”Reaching For The Rail”, ”Far From the Harbour Wall”

Rating: 4 out of 5.
Author: JANNE YLIRUUSI

Read also: Review: Pink Floyd – Animals (1977)


Tracks

  1. ”Breaking Water” 2:27
  2. ”Night of a Thousand Furry Toys” 4:23
  3. ”Hidden Fear” 3:28
  4. ”Runaway” 4:00
  5. ”Unfair Ground” 2:22
  6. ”Satellite” 4:05
  7. ”Woman of Custom” 3:44
  8. ”Interlude” 1:15
  9. ”Black Cloud” 3:20
  10. ”Far from the Harbour Wall” 6:08
  11. ”Drowning” 1:38
  12. ”Reaching for the Rail” 6:30
  13. ”Blue Room in Venice” 2:47
  14. ”Sweet July” 4:14
  15. ”Along the Shoreline” 4:36
  16. ”Breakthrough” 4:19


Richard Wright: keyboards, vocals, programming Anthony Moore: computer programming and arrangements, “phone vocals” (2) Sinéad O’Connor: vocals (12, 16) Tim Renwick: guitars Dominic Miller: guitars Steven Bolton: guitars Pino Palladino: bass guitar Manu Katché: drums, percussion Sian Bell: cello Kate St. John: oboe, English horn Maz Palladino: backing vocals

Producer: Richard Wright, Anthony Moore, Laurie Latham
Label: EMI

Vastaa

WordPress.com.

Up ↑